Consumer Rights And Product Liability-What Rights Have Consumers for Defective Products?


defective products law ireland

Consumer rights and product liability in relation to defective products are governed by a combination of protections such as common law which protects against tort or civil wrongs such as negligence.

The law of contract will also provide relief to the consumer in relation to defective products; legislation such as Liability for Defective Products act 1991, the Civil Liability Act of 1961 and other more modern European legislation including directives and regulations.

Liability For Defective Products Act 1991

Under this act the consumer does not need to prove negligence on behalf of the supplier or retailer; he/she merely needs to show that the product caused the consumer damage because of a defect in the product. Liability For Defective Products Act, 1991

2.—(1) The producer shall be liable in damages in tort for damage caused wholly or partly by a defect in his product. (Section 2 Liability for Defective Products Act 1991).

It is a strict liability therefore the consumer does not need to show any negligence on the part of the manufacturer. So you just need to show a link between the product and the damage suffered.

The Statute of Limitations, that is the time within which an action must be brought, is three years. There is also a long stop cut off point of 10 years, that is a claim may not be brought after 10 years from the introduction of the product into circulation.

Common Law-Negligence

The consumer will need to prove that the manufacturer owed a duty of care to the consumer, that that duty of care was not upheld, that there was loss or damaged incurred by the consumer as a result of the failure in relation to the duty of care and there was a close connection between the injury suffered and the conduct of the supplier/manufacturer.

By whom is the duty of care owed?

  1. Manufacturers-there is a duty of care owed by a manufacturer to those who may foreseeably be damaged or injured by the product
  2. Repairers-garages repairing motor cars is an example
  3. Installers and assemblers
  4. Suppliers for reward are also potentially liable
  5. Retailers, although their duty may be narrower than a manufacturer’s

To whom is the duty owed?

The ultimate consumer of the product.


The consumer must show that the negligent supply/manufacture of the product caused injury or damage to the plaintiff or his property.

The principle of res ipsa loquitur applies in product liability case.

Learn more about negligence here.

Sale of Goods Act

The Sale of Goods Act 1893 and the Sale of Goods And Supply of Services Act 1980 state that the supplier has a contractual duty to the consumer in relation to the consumer in respect of defects in his product. It is difficult to recover under this act against a manufacturer as your contract will be with the retailer.

European Legislation

Various pieces of European legislation such as the European Directive on Product Liability and the European Communities (General Product Safety) Regulations 2004 also provide protection to the consumer in relation to defective and dangerous products.

Under the Liability For Defective Products Act 1991 liability is strict and no duty of care needs to be established and this is why it will be used on many occasions along with perhaps a legal action for breach of contract and/or negligence.

The time within which you can bring an action under the various headings above varies from 2 years in relation to a personal injury claim to 6 years for breach of contract under the Sale of Goods Act.

If you are unfortunate enough to suffer as a result of a dangerous/defective product make sure to retain the evidence carefully including the product itself, any invoices/receipts and a good note of where and when you purchased it.

National Consumer Agency

The National Consumer Agency is a good source of information in this whole area as it has some pretty strong powers under the Consumer Protection Act of 2007.